Progesterone Cream, Flax Seed, and a Soy Supplements

Last Modified: December 14, 2003

Question

Dear OncoLink "Ask The Experts,"
My breast surgeon strongly recommends that I use topical natural progesterone cream, flax seed, and a soy supplement to decrease my risk of recurrent Stage IIB breast cancer. I am incorporating soy into my diet via soymilk and am adding flax seed to my soy breakfast cereal. I'm unsure, though, about how safe progesterone cream would be for me. I certainly want to do everything I can to prevent recurrence but I'm afraid the progesterone may "feed" any remaining cancer cells. What are your thoughts on someone with my history using progesterone cream? 

Answer

Katrina Claghorn, MS, RD, Registered Dietitian at the Abramson Cancer Center of the University of Pennsylvania, responds:

There is currently too little information available on the effect of progesterone creams, flaxseed and soy on breast cancer. Phytoestrogens (plant estrogens) are present in soy foods and to a much lesser extent in flax seed. The assumption is that the plant estrogens may bind to the estrogen receptor sites, thus preventing the body's estrogen form binding and activating the cancer process. However, there is the possibility that phytoestrogens may act as triggers and actually increase cancer risk. Unfortunately the research is equivocal. The current recommendation is to limit your intake of foods containing plant estrogens to no more than 50 mg a day.

Topical use of progesterone cream is another issue that is has been investigated even less. Until there is more information on the effects of progesterone cream in women with a history of breast cancer, especially those that are PR+, we would advise against using these products.

Keywords

Click on any of these terms for more related articles

Blogs

How to Find the Cancer Resources You Need - Brown Bag Web Chat
by OncoLink Editorial Team
June 15, 2011

Breaking news: Supreme Court votes to uphold Affordable Care Act Subsidies
by Christina Bach, MSW, LCSW, OSW-C
June 26, 2015

Related News

Soy Supplement Doesn't Cut Prostate Cancer Recurrence

Jul 10, 2013

No reduction in biochemical recurrence within two years of radical prostatectomy


Soy Isoflavones Don't Reduce Breast Epithelial Proliferation

Feb 9, 2012

Soy supplementation is ineffective therapy for healthy women at risk for breast cancer


AUA: Diet Supplements May Not Prevent Prostate Cancer

Jul 1, 2015

More than a quarter of men in study developed cancer with no risk benefit to treated group


From the National Cancer Institute