Low dose involved field radiation (IFRT) or no further treatment following complete response to initial chemotherapy in young adult (YA) patients 16-21years of age with Hodgkin's disease (HD): The Children's Cancer Group (CCG) experience
Reviewer: Walter Sall, MD
Last Modified: May 16, 2005
Presenter: J. Nachman
Presenter's Affiliation: Children's Hospital, Redmond, WA
Type of Session: Scientific
- Little data exist regarding treatment outcomes in HD patients aged 16-21 years. The optimal combination of chemotherapy with or without radiation has yet to be defined.
Materials and Methods
- 227 patients age 16-21 with newly diagnosed HD were entered on the CCG 5942 study.
- Following clinical staging, patients received risk adapted chemotherapy per protocol. Stage I-III patients received 4-6 cycles of COPP/ABV chemotherapy. Stage IV patients received 6 cycles of combination chemotherapy including high dose Ara-C, VP-16, COPP/ABV and high dose CHOP.
- Complete Responders (CR) were randomized to 21Gy involved field RT (IFRT) vs no further therapy. Partial responders (PR) all recieved 21Gy IFRT.
- Complete response was defined as no visible disease on restaging CT scans OR >70% reduction in tumor volume and conversion of all sites of gallium positive disease to gallium negative.
- Patients were 16-21 years old. 67% were stage I,II, 40% had bulk disease, 86% had nodular sclerosing HD and 76% had ESR >20.
- Of 227 enrolled patients, 215 completed protocol chemotherapy. 168 achieved a CR while 46 had a PR. 60 patients were randomed to receive IFRT while 56 patients were randomized to no further therapy.
- Overall 5 yr EFS was 83% and OS was 93%
- By treatment arm, 5 yr EFS was 93% and 76% (p=0.013) for IFRT and no IFRT, respectively. Corresponding 5 yr OS was 100% and 93% (p=0.056)
- Failures occurred early. In the no IFRT arm, 90% of failures occurred within what would have been treated by IFRT. Most of these failures were seen in patients receiving only 4 cycles of chemotherapy.
- Adolescent HD patients are more likely to have bulk disease, B symptoms and nodular sclerosing histology than younger patients, perhaps making them more likely to benefit from radiation.
- EFS was significantly improved in this group of patients with the addition of IFRT.
- A trend towards improved OS with IFRT was seen (p=0.056).
- B symptoms and bulk disease were associated with a higher risk of recurrence.
In this study, adolescent patients were seen to have more high risk features than their younger counterparts. Perhaps because of this, improved outcomes were seen with the addiation of 21 Gy IFRT. Better risk stratification is needed. In the no IFRT arm, most failures occurred in patients receiving only 4 cycles chemo. If these patients could be prospectively identified and given more chemotherapy, perhaps RT could be avoided safely. However, until better risk stratification becomes available and further randomized studies are completed, low dose IFRT will remain a part of the standard treatment of adolescent HD patients.
I Wish You Knew
How cancer patients have changed my life
Blogs and Web Chats
OncoLink Blogs give our readers a chance to react to and comment on key cancer news topics and provides a forum for OncoLink Experts and readers to share opinions and learn from each other.
Facing a new cancer diagnosis or changing the course of your current treatment? Let our cancer nurses help you through!